No Wind Event Found in Florida Roof Damage Claim
No Wind Event Found in Florida Roof Damage Claim
US · Published Aug 28, 2026
A breach of contract case in Florida's Seventh Judicial Circuit centered on alleged wind and hail damage to a roof on April 27,
The insurer, First Protective Insurance Company (Frontline), denied the claim after an investigation found no evidence of wind or hail damage on the reported date. During litigation, a second engineering report confirmed the absence of a wind event on that date. While some shingles showed damage consistent with wind, it was determined not to be related to the reported weather event. The court granted summary judgment in favor of the insurer, citing a lack of evidence from the plaintiffs to dispute the findings. The case also highlighted policy exclusions for wear, tear, and defective materials.

Impact & Risks

The ruling underscores the importance of providing substantial evidence in insurance claims involving weather-related damages. Homeowners in Florida and other regions prone to severe weather events may face challenges in proving causation for damages, especially when policies include exclusions for wear and tear or defective materials. This case also highlights the potential financial risks for insurers, as it involved exposure to one-way attorney’s fees and an expired civil remedy notice, which could have significantly increased the insurer's liability.

Related News